Showing posts with label speech. Show all posts
Showing posts with label speech. Show all posts

Sunday, December 22, 2013

Quick Hits on the Duck Dynasty Fiasco


Quick Hits

“A&E has free speech rights too, and they exercised those rights.”
Certainly. And they lost an enormous chunk of business. There’s no law against stupidity—mainly because it would be too hard to prosecute every politician in D.C.
Second thought: Was it really an exercise of free speech by A&E? Or was it caving to GLAAD’s demands for punishment?
Third thought: A&E is a business—a business that sacked its top tier moneymaker, and intentionally jeopardized it’s best show. Someone online asked: “does GLAAD pay A&E’s bills?” Probably not. It’s the people that watch A&E? …err…used to watch A&E.
Fourth thought: A&E’s business is to make money via network television. Delving into matters of belief and morality was obviously beyond the scope of their best interests. But they feared GLAAD more than their customers and now the rest is history. This is the same reason that singers and bands should stay out of politics. I don’t care what their politics are…I’m just here for the music. I’ve got an internet full of punditry if I need it.

“Was firing/suspending Phil Robertson wrong?”
Ethically: Probably borderline. There’s a good case for “the boss does what he wants” but also a good case for being fired for irrelevant off-the-clock opinions.

Morally: Dicey. An external group pressured Phil’s bosses to pull him. That’s like me talking your boss into firing you because I don’t agree with your belief. Sketchy.

Business: Yes. A&E just shot their cash cow on their little duck hunt. Dick Cheney now takes Second Place for the “Dumbest Thing Someone Shot While Duck Hunting” award. It was the wrong business decision. Pissing your customers off is always the wrong decision. (Hey at least Cracker Barrel got the memo).

“A&E just wanted to distance themselves and disassociate from Robertson’s remarks.”
That’s a weak argument for two reasons.
First, it requires the faith of a canonized saint to really believe that in 4 years of filming this family’s everyday lives that A&E did not ever find out the Robertson’s beliefs on homosexuality. This then reveals a viable theory: A&E knew their beliefs and ran the show anyway. In other words, Phil could believe it, but the moment he expressed that belief they caved to GLAAD and canned him. That would make the suspension about nothing other than speech.
Second, as the Twitterverse (@AceofSpadesHQ) pointed out, A&E is still running the Duck Dynasty Marathon and presumably reruns—all with Phil in them. They’re actively running new content from Phil. If they REALLY wanted true separation they’d stop running all Duck Dynasty content with Phil in it. Oh wait. They need the money.

“This whole thing is a ploy, a fabrication, a conspiracy.”
If so, by whom?
The Ducks? Canning themselves? Why? Just quit…they didn’t need a scandal for that.
GQ? Possibly, but only in the sense of “hey let’s get a Christian conservative traditionalist in for an interview and ask him about gays.” That’s journalism? That would make GQ the most predictably boring magazine in the world. Seriously…what did they THINK he was going to say?
A&E? On the one hand, it makes sense. Get someone to bait Phil into something controversial, make a stink, get attention, and then watch the ratings soar. Not a bad plan…if not for the (now very real) backlash risk involved. Kind of a long shot for that to be true. It’s a multi-million dollar gamble on A&E’s part—with a lot to lose. 


“This is dumb…while everyone was griping about Phil, Congress passed XYZ.”
On the one hand, yes, people pay too much attention to entertainment figures instead of rotten politicians.
On the other hand, I’d argue that this incident generated steam because it was about freedom of expression, and it brought people into the fray who don’t even watch Duck Dynasty. In other words the issue was bigger than the entertainment factor. Being able to speak your mind without fear is a universally desired standard.
Also, Congress would have done business as usual, Phil or no. The Phil-Incident happening did not distract the people from D.C. long enough to sneak something through. Congress would ram anything through, whether anyone is watching or not. Proof? ObamaCare. It’s never enjoyed majority support, and probably never will. If the American people had voted on it, it would never have passed. Congress passed it anyway, in full view of the public.



Gay writers

A few homosexuals have actually sided with Robertson. Yes, you read that right. What’s interesting is that they see this as a freedom of expression issues first and foremost. Gay CNN Anchor Don Lemon said, “I always err on the side of free speech. Just because I’m offended — as I said, people can say whatever they want to say. I don’t think people should be fired. I think the marketplace should decide.”1 In short, Don Lemon handled this way better than A&E did—and note his stance: it’s based on free speech.



Camille Paglia, a lesbian author, teacher, and social critic wasn’t so passive in her remarks. She called the action against Robertson, “punitive” and “Stalinist”. “People have the right to free thought and free speech. In a democratic country, people have the right to be homophobic as they have the right to support homosexuality -- as I 100% do. If people are basing their views against gays on the Bible, again they have a right to religious freedom,” she said on a radio interview.2 Paglia seems to understand something about free speech: you can’t be choosy about what’s “ok” and what’s not. Perhaps it’s because she’s been on the “wrong” side of the line everyone is so fond of drawing.



Tammy Bruce is the former head of NOW, a feminist activist group, and a lesbian. She tweeted, “The gay civil rights effort was about making sure we weren't punished for being who we are. [It's] Time the left applies that same value to others.”4



But perhaps the most poignant quote comes from Brandon Abrosino, a gay writer at Time magazine’s online site. He wrote that, “I’m undecided on whether or not I think Phil actually is homophobic, although I certainly think his statement was offensive . . . But I also think that if I were to spend a day calling ducks with Phil, I’d probably end up liking him — even in spite of his position on gay men. It’s quite possible to throw one’s political support behind traditional, heterosexual marriage, and yet not be bigoted.”3 That’s profound. Brandon’s punch line, as a leftie is: “Why is our go-to political strategy for beating our opponents to silence them?” It’s a great question, and one that I don’t expect the political left to want to answer.







Sources
















Thursday, August 30, 2012

Paul Ryan - An Effortless Performance



            Paul Ryan’s acceptance speech to the RNC may be one of the best political speeches of the year—if not out of the last four years. It’s strengths were many, and it’s weaknesses few, and the delivery was impeccably good. It wasn’t entirely “safe”, but neither was it the politically risky ranting and raving that makes people uncomfortable. He was idealistic without being unrealistic, and realistic without being a doomsayer. He was funny without being a clown, heartfelt without the sappiness, and pointedly brutal without coming off as a douche. He spoke clearly, and succinctly, proving that brevity is indeed the soul of wit—wit without being an unlikeable know-it-all.
            Love him, hate him, or indifferent, there are several truths each side should recognize: first, it was a killer delivery of one hell of a speech. The crowd loved it, and perhaps the nation did too. Paul Ryan came off as a very easy guy to like and to listen to. The speech could have been ten minutes longer, and Ryan still would have had the crowd in his pocket. Second, Mitt Romney has three very tough acts to follow: Mrs. Romney, Condy, and Paul Ryan. Making it even tougher on Mitt will be Clint Eastwood’s address, and the scrutiny of the nation coming off the Olympics with a scorecard mentality. Mitt Romney survived debates, and hit singles when faced with fastballs. But the last three batters hit home runs. Mitt Romney simply surviving and "paring the course" won’t be anywhere near enough. Mitt Romney’s greatest challenge Friday night will be to end the convention with an energetic bang that motivates the base and the undecided voters of the country.
            Perhaps the greatest challenge facing the democrats after Ryan’s speech is the third truth, a cold reality for Team Obama: Joe Biden is no match for Paul Ryan. Biden tries to be likeable, but Paul Ryan is likeable. Joe Biden comes off as an arrogant jerk, Paul Ryan as a friendly intellectual. Biden is an awkward, embarrassing bull in a china closet, yet Ryan is relaxed, inspiring, and precise. Biden flounders, but Ryan delivers. For Joe Biden, Paul Ryan is a nightmare Biden cannot wake from. Whatever Paul Ryan may have done on Thursday night, one thing is for certain: Joe Biden can neither replicate nor match it.

Monday, August 6, 2012

Defeathering the Chick-Fil-A Meme



Time for a de-meme-ing of sorts…


This meme shouldn’t have any traction for a few reasons—mostly logical reasons.

-       There's no evidence that it was mostly Christian supporters that showed up. That's a logical fallacy, called "sweeping generalization". Some may have been Christian, but some does not justify all. There are no statistics suggesting the CFA supporters were even greater than 50% Christian. One cannot take “there were some Christians” and make it, “Christians”, as in all. For many, this was about freedom of speech.

-       Logically, Jesus is ok with the "biblical definition of marriage” and supporting it. One can be pretty sure Jesus doesn’t mind people supporting a man that publically places faith in Him and the Bible He wrote.

-       Contrary to the meme, one will see that many Christians have lined up to help others. http://www.theblaze.com/stories/viral-chick-fil-a-picture-claims-christians-dont-feed-the-poor-but-we-have-proof-to-the-contrary/


-       Operation Christmas Child, World Vision, Operation Blessing, Samaritan’s Purse, Salvation Army, hundreds of city missions across the US, hundreds of Crisis Pregnancy Centers, JAF Ministries, Koinanea House, Mission Aviation Fellowship, New Tribes Mission, thousands of churches with Food Pantries, Habitat for Humanity, Mercy Ships, Christian Aid Ministries, and the list goes on and on and on. These aren’t flash mobs. These are Christian organizations that take a lot of money and manpower to run, year in and year out. If someone thinks that “Christians aren’t doing anything” maybe it’s because they’re not involved in what Christians are doing. Ironically, many food banks and homeless shelters are run by Christians. A more accurate statement might be that one would never see this many LGBT supporters lining up to help any of the above organizations.

-       The nature of the meme suggests two sources: a self-loathing, handwringing Christian, who, (as stated above) probably isn’t involved much with aid organizations of any kind. Or secondly, a liberal who very subtly is trying to slip the hypocrisy accusation into a catchy meme. Either way, self-righteous ignorance is a theme here, and that’s why the meme is busted.